I like the idea of that story. The idea that you take a bullet for someone that is Christian shows that you don't need to believe in a God to be a good person. The fact that the Atheist gives his life for a Christian and then is sent to hell makes the Christian God look evil. The fact that according to Christianity all Atheist would go to hell makes the storyline work out well. Someone could live a completely good life but if they didn't believe in the holy spirit they would burn. Sounds like a nice God to me.
